Varsity.com Message Boards
03/19/10, 07:53 pm *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: Varsity.com Forums Back Online!
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1]   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: MMA is safer than Cheerleading - or so this article claims  (Read 1421 times)
ucaCHEERalum
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 29
Offline Offline

Posts: 286


College Cheer Coach

« on: 07/02/09, 08:20 am »

When it rains...

http://blog.fightmagazine.com/mmas-sporting-double-standard-923/comment-page-1/#comment-233

...the knuckleheads come out.
Logged

?
Jen H
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 5
Offline Offline

Posts: 368


« Reply #1 on: 07/02/09, 09:00 am »

"But because cheerleading is part of Americana, and therefore understood on some level, it won’t be attacked, while rejecting mixed martial arts has become a standard for the mainstream."


"The collective injury record of MMA in North America since its November 10, 1993 debut–and in those days, it wasn’t monitored, thus it was far more dangerous than it is now–seems to be far emptier than high school’s yearly ledger."



Have you thought about leaving a note refuting these lines and explained to the author that we feel every bit as scapegoated due to skewed stats?
« Last Edit: 07/02/09, 09:02 am by Jen H » Logged

Adams School, K-8 with 55 students: "A little small but best of all!"
ucaCHEERalum
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 29
Offline Offline

Posts: 286


College Cheer Coach

« Reply #2 on: 07/02/09, 09:06 am »

already did...see my comment after the article
Logged

?
Jen H
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 5
Offline Offline

Posts: 368


« Reply #3 on: 07/02/09, 09:38 am »

already did...see my comment after the article

I don't see anything but the leave a comment box. Not comments list. Sad  Glad you left one, though. Let us know if you get a reply!
Logged

Adams School, K-8 with 55 students: "A little small but best of all!"
Miss April
Full Member
***

Spirit Points! 6
Offline Offline

Posts: 205


« Reply #4 on: 07/02/09, 10:16 am »

I don't really see how balking about how unsafe cheerleading is makes  MMA any safer.

...its danger is more assumed than the real blunt force trauma that comes from falling ten feet in the air completely unprotected...

Who is "falling" from 10 feet "unprotected"?  Basket tosses are an advanced skill, and so advanced members only should be doing them.  I don't know of any bases (outdated youtube videos excluded) that would toss their flier then leave her unprotected.

...which makes [MMA] safer than the concussive blows of boxing, is more of a momentary threat than a prolonged headache...

I'm not the world's  most hardcore MMA fan, but I have watched it several times with my dad (former boxer and wrestler) and I would think that things such as repeated knees to the head would cause some injury similar to boxing.  There  are usually knock-outs in MMA too.


...It’s ban is simply a matter of misinformation and an unwillingness to learn...

Wow, this sounds familiar.  Roll Eyes  Almost like something that could be said regarding cheerleading injuries and their "statistics".

...Take the aggression directed toward mixed martial arts and employ that energy into fixing the cheerleading issue ... which will allow young women to explore other sports... less dangerous competitions...

That's nice.  I'm pretty sure most girls that are a part of a  cheerleading program ENJOY it, and I know many who do more sports then just cheer.  I think government involvement has a place much more in MMA then in cheerleading.

Thankfully I don’t have to devise any choregraphed cheers to inspire anyone to do anything.

So, according to this article cheerleading is horribly dangerous, and also not anything more then coreographed cheers?


I'll leave a comment (mostly the same thing I have just said here).  Let's see if it gets posted  Cheesy
Logged

College|Cheer|Athlete
ucaCHEERalum
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 29
Offline Offline

Posts: 286


College Cheer Coach

« Reply #5 on: 07/02/09, 10:58 am »

A bit of humor though...anyone notice the last line of the article???

"...who thought he would never fight again due to a rehabilitating motorcycle accident, after defeating Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira at UFC 92."

When was the last time you knew of anyone who had gone through a rehabilitating accident. 
Logged

?
VarsityMo
Mo - no E long O
Administrator
Hero Member
*****

Spirit Points! 8
Offline Offline

Posts: 958

Check out On Demand Videos on Varsity TV

« Reply #6 on: 07/02/09, 11:08 am »

I thought the article was a nice way of trying to divert attention from the politician in NY that has been against MMA and to try to throw some political backwash on the info that has come out this week. 

Isn't it funny how the media jumps on any type of negative sensationalism in our arena?  However they do not report or project the many many many positives that come out of cheerleading such as any type of community outreach acts, type of student athletes there are, the dedication to there activity, the endless support to their team, school, and communities, etc, etc, etc. 

Logged

V
ucaCHEERalum
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 29
Offline Offline

Posts: 286


College Cheer Coach

« Reply #7 on: 07/02/09, 11:45 am »

I don't see anything but the leave a comment box. Not comments list. Sad  Glad you left one, though. Let us know if you get a reply!

My response is still "awaiting moderation". 

But here is what I said...

Man-o-man do you have this way wrong…check your stats brother.

http://www.cheersafety.org/2009/06/cheerleading-and-media-again-again.html

I’m not saying that one is more dangerous than the other - but don’t trounce cheerleading for your gain.

The most dangerous sports out there are football, hockey, and gymnastics, followed by lacrosse and wrestling according to this study you undoubtedly got your info from.

May both sports gain the respect they deserve.

Logged

?
Jen H
Sr. Member
****

Spirit Points! 5
Offline Offline

Posts: 368


« Reply #8 on: 07/02/09, 11:57 am »

I don't see anything but the leave a comment box. Not comments list. Sad  Glad you left one, though. Let us know if you get a reply!

My response is still "awaiting moderation". 

But here is what I said...

Man-o-man do you have this way wrong…check your stats brother.

http://www.cheersafety.org/2009/06/cheerleading-and-media-again-again.html

I’m not saying that one is more dangerous than the other - but don’t trounce cheerleading for your gain.

The most dangerous sports out there are football, hockey, and gymnastics, followed by lacrosse and wrestling according to this study you undoubtedly got your info from.

May both sports gain the respect they deserve.



I always wonder where diving , ice skating, and downhill skiing fall in the "risk" range.

Hope they add your comments and respond, and that they "get" it.
Logged

Adams School, K-8 with 55 students: "A little small but best of all!"
Miss April
Full Member
***

Spirit Points! 6
Offline Offline

Posts: 205


« Reply #9 on: 07/02/09, 11:58 am »

ucaCHEERalum, I put that link in my comment too Cheesy
Logged

College|Cheer|Athlete
Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.4 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC
SMF Theme Designed by JG Styles
Based on the IPB Enhanced Theme by Ghost
Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!